Lando, on August 20 2010 - 07:28 PM, said:
See this is a good debate without name calling. This is what our union was built on. I do blame Farmer for the lack of organizing in our core industries along with his supporters. They have convinced some that what he has been doing with these numbers are acceptable and we agree that they are not. My point about the locals is that they are not committing yet blaming the IBT. Everyone needs to step up organizing not just Hoffa. People talk about it but don't so I have a hard time blaming all of it on Hoffa.
UPS Freight is not a complete disaster, it isn't a disaster at all. Tearing down the fact that these workers have improved their lives significantly isn't a disaster. The subcontracting issue sucks and I agree that it shouldn't happen that way and that's what the grievance procedure and future negotiations will remedy. Discounting all the other positives for these workers is short sighted. Organizing them and improving over the years is what's important. Too many times we didn't organize a freight company because it had to be Master Freight and as a result the industry has slipped away. We are famous for getting something and then picking it apart and convincing ourselves we shouldn't have done it. Self destruction when you have the best. The members of UPS Freight ratified their contract by a huge margin because they saw the long term benefits of a contract. Quit beating them up the issues will work themselves out over time because they have a contract. Rome wasn't built overnight and their contract will progress like all others have shown to.
The organizing department has targeted core industries in the past however, guys like Farmer, Gegare, Keegel, Slawson helped kill the plans because of who was or wasn't in charge. Farmer has manipulated these people into believing his bullshit using these guys as support for HIS program. I would suspect the clock is ticking down on him.
Gegare talking shit about Farmer and the organizing is crazy because he was their biggest defender when some were attacking Farmer. Enough about the Farm Team.
Hoffa didn't fuck up our union and it's not fucked up now. We are going through a very difficult time and everyone has work to do. Clearly their are problems and those problems have ran deep for generations. Hoffa has put our union back on the map and cleaned it up according to Gegare. He unified our union again, he had a clear vision of rebuilding it according to Gegare. We all listen to Gegare for the last 15 years talk about how great Hoffa was(and himself) until now. Was he lying then or now or both. Anyway you look at it it doesn't work.
It's time for lots of people to retire and let the next generation but why would they do that?
Well I appreciate the conversation but must disagree.
Hoffa must take responsibility for the failures at the IBT. Farmer is not organizing in core industries but Hoffa controls that. Hoffa is the boss and he controls and directs the organizing department. There is no getting around that. Hoffa just does not understand the importance of organizing to support our core industries or pension funds. If he did he would have been doing that for the last 12 years.
UPS Freight is a complete disaster and obviously you don't talk to or represent these members. They say they were all better off without the Teamsters and will vote against Hoffa and Hall.
Funny you blame Farmer, Keegel, Gegare, and Slawson for the lack of organizing. Hoffa, Hall, Murphy, Deaner, Thompson, and Smith are making the decisions up there. That's why things are so fucked up and that's why they left.
And if you don't think the IBT is fucked up I don't know what more to say. You are right that folks should move on. We have given Hoffa 12 years and the union today is worse off than it was and continues to get worse. I will not stand for that and allow him another 5 years to tear down our union. Hoffa is 69 years old, he is a millionaire, and he needs to move on so a younger, more energetic group of leaders takes control and strenghtens our union.